Aaliyah Puglia was voted out in Survivor 51’s premiere after Toka lost the first challenge and faced a live Tribal Council. She and Jenna Doore both played their Shots in the Dark, but neither succeeded, so votes against them counted; Aaliyah received the most.
At Tribal, Devin Way said he would vote for Jenna because he feared she could win, while Patt Canaday proposed Aaliyah as the alternative. Brady Booker campaigned against Aaliyah after Jenna told him she had targeted him for elimination.
